A business wins a large new customer. The sales team wants to pursue two more. Operations has identified an opportunity to improve productivity. The leadership team is considering a new service offering. Meanwhile, an expansion opportunity has appeared in another market.
All of these may be good opportunities. The problem is that they are competing for the same people, money and management attention.
This is where many business strategies begin to lose their effectiveness.
Leadership teams spend considerable time deciding what they want to achieve. They discuss growth targets, new markets, customer opportunities and improvement projects. Far less time is spent examining what the business will have to give up to pursue them.
For an organisation with limited resources, that omission matters.
A strategy cannot be a list of everything the business would like to achieve. It has to establish which opportunities deserve priority and which ones the organisation is prepared to leave alone.
The cost of pursuing too many opportunities
Consider a professional services business with 40 employees.
The business has a good reputation and wants to grow. Its leadership team identifies four opportunities:
- Develop a new service offering.
- Pursue larger corporate clients.
- Expand into another geographic market.
- Improve its existing service delivery systems.
The team approves all four.
On paper, this looks like an ambitious growth programme. In practice, the same senior employees are expected to lead the projects while maintaining existing client relationships and managing their teams.
The business has not increased its management capacity. It has simply increased the demands placed on it.
The consequences are predictable. Project decisions take longer. Experienced employees are stretched across several responsibilities. Existing customers receive less attention. Some initiatives progress, but none receives the level of focus originally intended.
The business may eventually complete all four projects, but the question is whether the results justify the resources consumed along the way.
There is also an opportunity cost. Time spent developing a new service cannot be spent improving an existing one. Management attention given to expansion is attention taken away from current operations.
The financial impact is not limited to project expenditure. It can include delayed revenue, reduced productivity, missed customer opportunities and additional pressure on employees.
These costs rarely appear together in the original business case.
Why saying no is part of strategy
Michael Porter addressed this issue directly in his Harvard Business Review article, What Is Strategy?.
His argument is that a sustainable competitive position requires trade-offs. Businesses need to choose how they compete, because trying to serve every market and meet every customer requirement can create incompatible demands on the organisation.
This is particularly relevant to businesses pursuing growth.
A company may have the capability to serve a particular customer, but that does not automatically make the customer commercially attractive. A new service may generate revenue, but it may also require different systems, skills and delivery processes. A new market may offer potential, but entering it could distract management from strengthening the business’s existing position.
The decision should not be based solely on whether an opportunity is available.
It should be based on whether pursuing it makes sense for the business and the position it wants to establish.
This is also why revenue growth and business growth are not always the same thing. Additional revenue can come with higher delivery costs, more complex operations and demands that reduce the profitability of existing work.
Leaders need to understand what they are taking on before they commit.
The four questions to ask before approving another initiative
A useful way to improve strategic decisions is to examine every significant opportunity against four questions.
1. Does the opportunity fit the business we are trying to build?
A new customer or market may look attractive, but does it fit the organisation’s chosen direction?
For example, a specialist service business may have built its reputation around technical expertise and a high level of customer support. It is then offered a large contract that depends heavily on price competition.
The contract could increase turnover. However, delivering it may require lower margins, additional employees and a different operating model.
If the business wants to compete through expertise and service quality, it needs to consider whether this contract supports that position.
The same test applies to new products, services and markets. An opportunity should be assessed against the business’s intended competitive position, not just its potential revenue.
2. What will it actually take to deliver?
Business cases often include financial estimates and expected returns. They do not always account for the management and employee capacity required.
Before approving an initiative, identify:
- The person accountable for delivering it.
- The specialist skills and employees required.
- The management time involved.
- The effect on existing customers and operations.
- The additional systems or processes needed.
The leadership team should also ask whether the required people are genuinely available.
Assigning someone responsibility for a project does not create additional capacity if that person already has a full workload.
3. What will receive less attention?
This question should be part of every major investment decision.
If the business commits to developing a new service, what happens to its existing service improvement programme? If senior managers focus on entering another market, who will oversee current operations?
The answer should be made explicit.
Otherwise, the organisation ends up with several initiatives that all have senior management support but compete for the same resources.
This is not simply a workload issue. It affects the quality of decisions, the speed of implementation and the business’s ability to maintain existing performance.
4. Is this something to pursue now, later or not at all?
Some opportunities are worth retaining for the future.
A business may want to expand geographically but first needs to strengthen its management structure. It may want to introduce a new service but needs to improve its existing delivery processes.
There is a difference between deliberately postponing an opportunity and leaving it on the business plan without a decision.
If an initiative is deferred, establish what needs to change before it is reconsidered. That might be a particular revenue level, available management capacity or completion of another project.
Without clear reasoning, deferred initiatives tend to reappear at the next planning session.
What leadership teams should review
The next step is to examine the commitments the business has already made.
This is best done before developing another annual plan or approving another round of projects.
Ask the people responsible for delivery to review the current initiatives with the leadership team. Look at their original objectives, current progress, resource requirements and expected contribution to the business.
Then make four decisions:
| Decision | What it means |
|---|---|
| Continue | The initiative supports the strategy and has a reasonable case for investment. |
| Stop | The expected value no longer justifies the resources required. |
| Defer | The opportunity remains relevant, but the business is not ready to pursue it. |
| Reduce | The work is worthwhile, but its scope or resource requirements should be smaller. |
The important part is to follow through.
If the leadership team decides to stop a project, the resources assigned to it need to be released. If an initiative is deferred, it should not continue consuming management attention in the background.
The business should also communicate these decisions to employees. People need to understand which activities remain important and which commitments have changed.
For Australian SMEs, this discipline is particularly relevant. In a business with 20 to 100 employees, the people responsible for growth initiatives are often the same people managing customers, supervising operations and solving daily problems. There is limited room to keep adding projects without affecting something else.
The decision that makes a strategy meaningful
A.G. Lafley and Roger Martin’s strategy framework in Playing to Win asks leaders to make choices about where to play, how to win, the capabilities required and the management systems needed to support those choices.
These decisions are connected. Choosing a market has implications for the services offered, the people required and the way the organisation operates.
This is why strategic priorities cannot be developed in isolation from business capacity.
A leadership team might agree that entering a new market is important. But if the organisation lacks the management capability, financial resources or delivery systems to support it, the decision needs further consideration.
The same applies to growth targets. Setting a higher target does not automatically give the business the capacity to achieve it.
Before approving the next opportunity, leadership teams should examine their existing commitments and decide whether those commitments still deserve their resources.
The question is not how many opportunities your business can identify. It is how many it can pursue successfully without compromising the performance of the business it already has.
That is a much more useful starting point for strategy development.












